define('DISABLE_WP_CRON', true); _sh1ft.org » bringing up baby

bringing up baby

there’s been a controversial series on the tele about 3 different methods of bringing up your baby.

Bringing Up Baby takes the guiding principles of three of last century’s most influential childcare manuals – Dr Truby King’s 1913 book Feeding and Care of Baby, Dr Benjamin Spock’s Baby and Child Care and Jean Liedloff’s 1975 The Continuum Concept – and observes six families as they put into practice their chosen method for the first few months of their babies’ lives.

i’ve been watching, through cringing eyes and a sad heart. while i think help is good and guidance is fine, i’m a true believer on instinct, even as a new mum. following a book was just not for me. it’s great to have one around to consult (e.g. I have The Wonder Weeks, which is great to open my mind as to what could be going on), but i could never put my babies outside in the cold by themselves for hours while i enjoy a glass of wine, just because a book told me to. i could never NOT cuddle and kiss and spend time with my newborn, just because a book told me to. i certainly do not think my baby is manipulating me and is an attention seeker when she vomits or cries. what the?

like i said, we won’t know everything about how to raise a baby whether we’ve done it before or not, and i know they’re doing this for the sake of the tv program. it’s an interesting series, no doubt. but to see those new parents get beat down is distressing and seeing those babies go without a cuddle, just sucks :/

have you seen Bringing Up Baby?

This entry was posted is filed under parenthood, ramblings. Both comments and pings are currently closed.

PamelaFebruary 28th, 2009 at 1:06 am

I’m going to search for this show. And I agree I could never go by a book, I like to read what he COULD be doing (like his development) but I couldn’t let a book tell me how to parent. And I don’t see why someone wouldn’t cuddle & kiss their newborn, I can’t help but grab Micah and plant kisses all over him. Okey now you have me going into my own ramblings :p

LanaFebruary 28th, 2009 at 1:44 pm

I have the Wonder Weeks too. I like peeking ahead to see what’s coming up. I’d be curious to see the show – are the parents who are doing the older methods happy with it? I can’t imagine doing that to my baby for the sake of tv. : (

lindsey clareMarch 4th, 2009 at 11:17 am

i’ve been watching this series, and i completely agree. it is VERY cringe-worthy. i particularly can’t stand it when the three ‘experts’ argue. get some perspective, ladies!

it is quite hideous how these families are being dictated to. some of them seem so obviously clueless and needing help, but i can’t help but feel like they’re being set up for a fall. especially the Truby King families – my husband and i could barely stand to watch how they weren’t allowed to even LOOK at their babies, let alone hold or cuddle them.

but having said all that, i’m still watching it! so maybe i am the sucker 😉